A letter writer calls for budget transparency and questions whether Highline’s proposal to close Maritime High School while keeping CHOICE Academy open is equitable.

[Editor’s note: The writer is a former Highline resident who recently moved out of the area, and who requested anonymity.]

[The Highline Journal asked Highline Public Schools how it calculated the projected $2.1 million in savings and whether the board will receive that breakdown before discussing the proposed closure tonight. The district responded: "this information will be shared tonight at the board meeting."]


To Members of the Highline Public Schools Board, Media Representatives, Government Officials and Industry Partners,

We are writing to request full transparency regarding the budget figures behind the proposed closure of Maritime High School and the district's claim of $2.1 million in savings. This seems to be just it - a claim. Not based on the actual facts and the actual budget the district says to have and be working with.  

A closer look at the district's own allocated resources and staffing numbers—which represent the largest expense, as non-staffing budgets are nearly identical across both small schools—tells a very different story. For FY 2027, the total allocated resources begin at $2.1 million for Maritime High School and $1.8 million for Choice Academy.

However, those beginning numbers include restricted, dedicated funding streams that do not represent general fund savings:

  • Port of Seattle Funding : $126k for Maritime ($0.00 for Choice)
  • CTE Funding : $256k for Maritime vs. $85k for Choice

Once these restricted grant and CTE funds ($382k total for Maritime vs. $85k for Choice) are subtracted from the staffing totals, Maritime's remaining general staffing cost is $1.5 million—over $185,000 less than Choice Academy's remaining total of $1.7 million. How can the district claim $2.1 million in general savings when it is counting external Port of Seattle grant money and dedicated CTE funds in that total, and when Maritime actually costs less in general staffing funds than Choice Academy?

Beyond the flawed math, this decision raises serious questions about equity and priorities. Maritime High School is an innovative model with a proven track record of sending students directly into living-wage careers in the maritime industry. Meanwhile, Choice Academy functions like a mini comprehensive high school that does not offer distinct workforce pathways beyond what is already available at traditional high schools.

This forces the community to ask why an innovative career pipeline is on the chopping block instead of Choice Academy. Choice serves many families from Marvista and North Hill—the same North Hill community that mobilized in droves last year when the district tried to move their administrators to another school. Is the Superintendent avoiding the harder, right decision to close Choice and keep Maritime open simply to avoid making that community mad again?

Highline Public Schools repeatedly states that it stands for equity and serving students furthest away from educational justice. Closing a vital, cost-effective pipeline to living-wage jobs directly contradicts that promise. We urge the Board and Superintendent to release a transparent accounting of these numbers, the true reasoning behind this inequitable, reconsider this recommendation, and keep Maritime High School open.


Thank you,
Concerned Citizen


[Note From the Editor: Letters to the Editor reflect the views of their authors and do not necessarily represent the opinions of The Highline Journal. If you wish to submit a letter, please include your name and contact info, and send comments to info@thehighlinejournal.com.]


LETTER: Highline Wants to Close Maritime. Did It Give the School a Fair Chance?
Former Highline resident questions Maritime High School’s closure, citing Port investment, student outcomes and concerns about district recruitment, funding and its fair chance to succeed.
Maritime High School Closure Recommendation Leaves Students Facing Uncertainty
Highline’s sudden closure announcement caught Maritime families off guard. Duran apologized for how the news was shared. Now 83 students face an uncertain future.
Maritime High School Graduates Sail Toward the Future
Superintendent Recommends Closure of Maritime High School
Superintendent Dr. Ivan Duran is recommending the closure of Maritime High School at the end of the 2026-27 school year, citing enrollment, financial sustainability and facility needs. The school board has not made a decision. Learn about the recommendation and opportunities for public input before the December 9 vote.
Share this article
The link has been copied!